test

Do Mormons believe in therapy or medicine?

Growing up I was taught that the sicknesses and problems we face are usually trials from God. So when I would give blessings or when people would give me blessings it was common to say something like, "but thy will be done" meaning that if God willed we suffer with whatever ailment then we would accept his will so that we could learn what ever it was God wanted us to learn. 

So, what are we saying to God if we go get medical attention for something we got blessed for? Isn't that like saying, "thy will be done, but I'm getting medical treatment to fix it regardless of thy will" 

In the church, every time we get medicine, a vaccine, or any other kind of help or treatment for something we are choosing to ignore God's will and instead solve the problem regardless of his will. When someone gets therapy, or when someone takes some kind of medication for psychological problems like ADHD or anxiety they are rejecting God's will that they suffer with those mental conditions. 

Basically my point is, if God has power and if faith can access that power then in the church we should only use priesthood blessings for all our ailments, if the blessing doesn't achieve the desired result then it must be God's will that we suffer with whatever we got blessed for. 

As a believer I thought that getting medical help after a blessing was somehow showing our faith or making sure we do our part to get God's help, but as I think about it now I don't think that's the case, I think any time we get medical help we are acknowledging that God might not help us and we have to help ourselves. 

Mormons who get blessings and take medicine have the same results as anyone who takes the medicine without the blessing. Statistically there is no difference, otherwise we would see news articles pointing out how Mormons seem to have different results from taking medicine than other people do. Either there would be stories about Mormons that stayed sick or got sick despite medicine or vaccines or there would be stories about Mormons that got better without health care. There are enough Mormons in the world at this point and have been enough for the past 20 years that someone would have noticed. I think the argument that you need to do your part is more applicable to physical injuries, like a cut, we need to wash it and bandage it and God will help it heal from there, if we have a limb cut off, we should bandage it and get a blessing that it will grow back, the fact there is no evidence anyone has ever had a limb grow back shows God doesn't help out with this process. Mental health issues seem like they should always be fixed by blessings, the spirit should be able to teach you how to communicate if you are having communication problems in a marriage. The spirit should be able to help you deal with anxiety or teach you how to deal with ADHD. No faithful Mormon should ever need therapy or drugs for mental problems. The point is, I think it's clear by the statistics in Utah, that the spirit doesn't teach people anything, which is why mental health and suicide is such a big problem in Utah*. I think it's also clear that the priesthood can't heal you which is why there is no statistically significant evidence that Utah heals better or requires less medicine** and there are no reports of any Mormon anywhere in any point in time, growing back a lost limb or having sight or hearing restored, which is why Elder Bednar gave his famous talk about having the faith to not be healed***. He knows priesthood blessings are no better than a placebo and he's trying to do some damage control as the rest of us also figure that out now that there is so much easy access to real-time information.  

** https://americanaddictioncenters.org/overdose/top-10-us-states, https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/emergency-room-visits-by-ownership/?activeTab=map&currentTimeframe=0&selectedDistributions=statelocal-government&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Location%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D (map shows that Utah has lower visit rates but other states that are not predominantly Mormon also have low rates), https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/public-health/us-coronavirus-deaths-by-state-july-1.html (death rate in Utah is low but other states that don't have many Mormons have lower death rates, so seems unlikely blessings are saving us, also the average age in Utah is 30 and the average age in Vermont is 42, they are dying less) 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments will be published unless they reveal personal identifying information about the commenter or the author.